Product Reviews

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray Review: A Compact Oven Air-Frying Set

A two-piece oven crisper tray for cooks who want air-fried-style results without adding a separate countertop appliance.

This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you.

For shoppers comparing gotham steel air fryer reviews, this two-piece crisper tray offers a way to use an oven or convection setting for foods usually cooked in a basket-style air fryer.

Its mesh basket, solid drip tray and nonstick coating make it worth considering if you want a compact setup for fries, wings and vegetables.

Gotham Steel Tray Review Summary

The quick verdict

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray
4.5/5

13,000+ ratings

Read Amazon Reviews

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray

A two-piece oven crisper tray for cooks who want air-fried-style results without adding a separate countertop appliance.

  • Two-piece setup: a raised mesh basket sits above a solid round tray.
  • The basket is designed to let hot air circulate around food during oven or convection cooking.
  • Round tray and basket are described as 12 inches; the product bullets also give the basket-and-tray size as 13.12 inches, so check the stated dimensions against your oven before purchase.
  • Copper-colored Gotham Steel Ti-Cerama coating covers the tray and basket for easier release.

Pros

  • The elevated mesh design encourages hot air to reach food from more sides than a solid pan alone.
  • A separate drip tray catches grease and crumbs, helping contain mess during cooking.

Consider before buying

  • The round format may use rack space differently from a rectangular sheet pan, so measure your oven and consider what else needs to fit.
  • This set relies on an oven or convection oven; it is not a standalone countertop air fryer.
Read the full review summary

The Gotham Steel Crisper Tray pairs a raised mesh basket with a solid round pan beneath it. The open basket is designed to let hot air circulate around food, while the pan catches grease and crumbs.

Its 12-inch round format and copper-colored Ti-Cerama coating bring together air-frying, baking and roasting uses in one oven accessory.

This set is best suited to cooks who already use an oven or convection oven and want a dedicated surface for crisping smaller portions.

The description says it fits most standard oven racks, small convection ovens and oven air-fryer models, but oven interiors vary; check the basket and tray dimensions against your usable rack space before buying.

The buying factors

Gotham Steel Tray Scorecard

Editorial scores reflect listed features and buyer fit; they are not laboratory measurements or customer ratings.

8/10

Airflow-oriented design

The raised mesh basket exposes food to circulating hot air, with a solid tray below to catch drips.

8/10

Cooking versatility

The set is described for air frying, baking, roasting and reheating in an oven.

8/10

Countertop footprint

It is a tray-and-basket accessory rather than a separate countertop appliance.

8/10

Cleanup convenience

The coated pieces are described as dishwasher safe, and the tray collects crumbs and grease.

6/10

Oven fit flexibility

The 12-inch round format is intended for many standard racks and compact ovens, though buyers should confirm their own clearance.

7/10

Material and coating details

The aluminum-core pieces use a titanium and ceramic nonstick coating and are described as free of PTHE, PFOA and PFOS.

Key Features and Specifications of Gotham Steel Tray

  • Two-piece setup: a raised mesh basket sits above a solid round tray.
  • The basket is designed to let hot air circulate around food during oven or convection cooking.
  • Round tray and basket are described as 12 inches; the product bullets also give the basket-and-tray size as 13.12 inches, so check the stated dimensions against your oven before purchase.
  • Copper-colored Gotham Steel Ti-Cerama coating covers the tray and basket for easier release.
  • Aluminum core with titanium and ceramic nonstick coating; described as free of PTHE, PFOA and PFOS.
  • Dishwasher-safe construction and a lower pan intended to catch grease and crumbs.
  • Designed for high-heat air-fry, bake and roast settings; the rim is described as easy to grasp with an oven mitt.

Pros and Cons of Gotham Steel Tray

Pros

  • The elevated mesh design encourages hot air to reach food from more sides than a solid pan alone.
  • A separate drip tray catches grease and crumbs, helping contain mess during cooking.
  • The two pieces can serve for air frying, baking, roasting or reheating.
  • The coated, dishwasher-safe construction is designed to simplify release and cleanup.

Consider before buying

  • The round format may use rack space differently from a rectangular sheet pan, so measure your oven and consider what else needs to fit.
  • This set relies on an oven or convection oven; it is not a standalone countertop air fryer.
  • The product information gives both 12-inch and 13.12-inch dimensions, so verify the exact size that applies to the set before ordering.

Who Should Buy Gotham Steel Tray?

Good fit

Consider the Gotham Steel Crisper Tray if you want to prepare fries, wings or vegetables in your oven with a basket-style setup.

The raised mesh basket keeps food above the solid pan, allowing air to circulate while drippings collect underneath.

It also makes sense for a kitchen where flexibility matters more than a single-purpose appliance.

The set is intended for air-fry, bake, roast and reheat modes, and the nonstick coating plus dishwasher-safe construction may suit cooks who want a simpler cleanup routine.

Before choosing it, measure the rack area and check the dimension discrepancy in the product information. Confirm that the round set can sit level with room for airflow and oven-mitt access in your particular oven.

Who should skip it

Skip this tray if you need an independent countertop appliance with its own heating system; this is an oven accessory and depends on the cooking modes and space your oven provides.

It may also be a poor fit if you need a large rectangular surface for family-size batches or want to keep other trays on the same rack. Check your usable oven area and typical portion size first.

How the Gotham Steel Tray Fits Oven Air Frying

A raised basket changes how food sits

The mesh basket lifts food above the solid tray, leaving open space beneath and around it. That arrangement is meant to support circulation during oven or convection cooking, while the lower pan catches drips and crumbs.

For best fit, leave enough clearance around the tray so the oven can circulate air as intended.

Round dimensions matter in real ovens

A 12-inch round tray can be convenient when rack space is limited, but the source also gives 13.12 inches for the basket-and-tray size.

Since usable oven space depends on rack width, rack depth and nearby cookware, measure the opening and the rack area rather than relying on a general fit description.

Coating and cleanup tradeoffs

The copper-colored Ti-Cerama finish is presented as nonstick, and the pieces are described as dishwasher safe.

That combination may reduce the work of releasing food and washing up, while the collection tray helps keep drippings from landing directly on the oven floor.

Follow the care guidance that comes with the product to preserve the coated surfaces.

A useful accessory for several cooking modes

Because the set is intended for air frying, baking, roasting and reheating, it can earn storage space beyond one kind of meal.

Its role is still shaped by your oven: cooks without convection or air-fry settings can use the pan as an oven tray, but the crisping approach described depends on the appliance's airflow and settings.

Alternatives to Gotham Steel Tray

Grill Baskets alternative

Cave Tools Vegetable Grill Basket
4.6/5

700+ ratings

Read Amazon Reviews

Cave Tools Vegetable Grill Basket

Choose the Gotham Steel set for oven-based air-frying and contained drips; consider the Cave Tools basket if your priority is grilling small foods outdoors and you want a stainless-steel basket with a carrying handle.

  • The Cave Tools basket is a dishwasher-safe stainless-steel grill basket with a curved handle, described for cooking vegetables, fruit, shrimp, fish and meat over a grill.
  • The Gotham Steel set is designed for oven cooking and includes a lower tray to collect grease and crumbs.

Grill Baskets alternative

Kona Smoker & Grill Basket
4.3/5

200+ ratings

Read Amazon Reviews

Kona Smoker & Grill Basket

Pick the Gotham Steel tray for oven use and a drip-catching pan. The Kona is a better match for outdoor grilling or cold smoking small foods, where its mesh format allows smoke and grill heat through.

  • The Kona is a 12-by-12-inch nonstick mesh basket for an outdoor grill or smoker, with a design intended to keep small foods from falling through and allow smoke to pass through.
  • The Gotham Steel tray is a round oven accessory with a mesh basket over a solid pan, intended for several oven cooking modes.

Is Gotham Steel Tray Worth It?

The Gotham Steel Crisper Tray is worth considering for cooks who want a dedicated oven accessory for air-fry-style cooking, with a raised mesh basket, a drip-catching pan and a coating designed for easier release.

Its multi-mode use and dishwasher-safe construction make it a practical option for regular oven cooking.

Buy after measuring your oven rack and confirming whether the 12-inch or 13.12-inch dimension describes the set you will receive.

It is a sensible fit for modest portions and oven users; those who need a standalone appliance or a broad rectangular cooking surface should look elsewhere.

Your review at a glance

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray
4.5/5

13,000+ ratings

Read Amazon Reviews

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray

A two-piece oven crisper tray for cooks who want air-fried-style results without adding a separate countertop appliance.

  • Two-piece setup: a raised mesh basket sits above a solid round tray.
  • The basket is designed to let hot air circulate around food during oven or convection cooking.
  • Round tray and basket are described as 12 inches; the product bullets also give the basket-and-tray size as 13.12 inches, so check the stated dimensions against your oven before purchase.
  • Copper-colored Gotham Steel Ti-Cerama coating covers the tray and basket for easier release.

Written by

russosbistro.com Editorial Team

Editorial team

Independent editorial coverage of coastal bistro cooking.

Amazon customer reviews

See what buyers think

Explore customer reviews, photos and available video reviews on Amazon.

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray

A two-piece oven crisper tray for cooks who want air-fried-style results without adding a separate countertop appliance.

  • Two-piece setup: a raised mesh basket sits above a solid round tray.
  • The basket is designed to let hot air circulate around food during oven or convection cooking.
Check Video Reviews on Amazon